May update
May is over and I managed to eliminate 6 more games from my backlog (2 from my ABC project) since the last update at the end of April.
Scribblenauts Unlimited : I play this one with my kids, in order to introduce them and get interested in video games, eventhough they can't play themselves yet. Since they can't read either, I describe what is asked on the screen and make them think about possible answers. The concept of the game is neat but it suffers one big flaw : translation. I play in French and a lot of the puzzles are based on puns in English. Therefore, many times, what you're asked to do remains hard to understand, even for a grown-up so imagine for a kid.
Verdict on Scribblenauts Unlimited : 5/10
Brothers : a tale of two sons : I played and beat B:atots in a "challenge me" event (out of BLAEO). It was as expected a nice story, emotional and of perfect length (not too short, not too long). I will remember the gameplay where you direct each brother with a side of the controller (stick and target) : it's savvy and challenging, because it requires a lot of coordination, and the gameplay fits nicely the subject of coop between the brothers.
Verdict on Brothers : a tale of two sons : 6,5/10
Mafia II : there's a lot to say about this one but since I'm a patient gamer and this game was released in 2010, I think you may have already read a lot about it.
First of all, I started it because I was recently gifted Mafia III, so I decided it was time to make the second episode before someday I started the third (and I know nothing about the first).
The strong point of the game for me is the story, the atmosphere and the characters. The missions are not "go there, kill this guy and bring back this thing". They are all about discovering little by little the mafia, from the base to the top level, with petty missions at first before getting a gun and finally becoming a "cleaner". Unfortunately, it looks like the game was never ended and had to be released unfinished by 2K, so the end is rather abrupt, raising more questions than delivering answers.
On the other hand, M2 is a semi-open-world : at first, I didn't realize since you're always in a mission and it looks like there's no free time to hang out freely. Well, in fact, you're not compelled to rush the missions and you could drive wherever you want before realizing the missions but since there are no activities like say in GTA IV (golfing, races…), there's no point to go off the rails. The only collectibles are Playboy girls' posters during the missions (OK, I confess it, I found these posters gorgeous [eventhough fussy spoilsports noted the posters - presented as part of an agreement with Playboy - depicted girls from late 50s and 60s while the story takes place in the 40s and early 50s]) and fake criminals' posters (with faces of 2K Czech devs) in the streets : that's very scarce to motivate me to visit the world. Consequently, it feels like the world is really thorough but the game doesn't make the most of it. It's just a beautiful background. Moreover, you're required to drive through the whole map on many occasions but driving sensations are dull and nothing happens during these drives.
The checkpoints enraged me a few times because I had to start over some tricky missions (one boss in particular was very hard to beat) but overall, the progression is not too steep.
So, in the end, the game could have been so great but it looks to me like a failed GTA IV. Both games take place in NY and in the mafia world but GTA IV managed to implement well many of the good ideas M2 failed. At first, I even thought M2 was released before GTA IV but it was released in 2010, 2 years after GTA IV !
Verdict on Mafia II : 7/10
Koi-koi Japan : not much to say about this one, except I picked it in my ABC project because at the time, it was the only K game I own. It's a little card game with Iroha cards, a japanese card game. I bought it in a deviant anime bundle but it's not racy at all. I kind of beat it by completing the campaign, but to shorten it, I admit I remained in level 1 difficulty, so the AI wasn't really competitive.
Verdict on Koi-koi Japan : 5/10
Call of Juarez : Gunslinger : the nice surprise of the month ! I'm usually not very much into FPS but I like almost anything Western-themed. I didn't play a lot of games set in the Old West : my best memory is of course Red Dead Redemption but CoJ:G reminded me a very old FPS I had played as a kid. I had to look for the title on Internet because all I had in mind were fleeting images : it turned out it's 1997 LucasArts' Outlaws that was in my mind. And it's funny how memories work : the video I watched on YT, to check if it was the game I remembered, was harsh with the images I had kept (or made up ?) in my memory. The graphics, already a bit dated when the game was released because using Dark Forces' Jedi engine, haven't aged well to say the least. And the levels feel so empty. The moral is : never look back at games you played and liked more than 10 years ago if you don't want your sweet memories to be crushed. :)
Anyway, back to CoJ:G : these graphics aged well since 2013 ;). In terms of game design, I was at first disappointed the levels weren't more open-world but took place in corridors, without any freedom of movement. They are also only flashbacks, without a linear progression, but the idea of the narrator changing his story because of erratic memories and how it influences the level design in real-time is brilliant.
There are a dozen of levels, that can all end in 2 ways : a boss fight or a duel. As always, some bosses fight were really boring for me (like when you have to fight guys with a Gatling) but on the other hand, the duels are another good and well implemented idea : it's a bit tricky because you have to deal with your opponent moves, keeping him in target with the mouse, while in the same time you also have to focus on your gun by putting your hand as close as possible of the grip ; and then, finally, it becomes a race when you have to react fast to draw the gun and aim when the other guy shows he's gonna shoot.
The story itself was a good surprise, with a very nice ending. And as an icing on the cake, the "nuggets of truth", which are collectibles to be found in the levels, reveal the more realistic and grim aspects of the wild West, often too much idealized when depicted in games and Hollywood movies.
Verdict on Call of Juarez : Gunslinger : 7,5/10
Hell Yeah ! : like B:atots and CoJ:G (sorry for the acronyms), HY! was assigned to me in a monthly "challenge me" event. This one didn't hit the target like the others : it was funny for half an hour, when you discover the frenzy, the 2nd degree humor and the mini-games (that means QTE). But once you encountered them once, you pretty much have seen all the possibilities and the rest is just "more of the same". The platform parts are dispensable and the game is very clumsy in how it shows you where to go : after every notch of mini-bosses beaten (there are 100 of them), the game rewards you with a long scrolling to show you the door to the next stage, eventhough it's often just at the end of a corridor, yet tortuous but still a corridor.
So, pun intended, HY! is repetitive as hell = NO.
Verdict on Hell Yeah ! : 4/10
I play this one with my kids, in order to introduce them and get interested in video games, even though they can’t play themselves yet. Since they can’t read either, I describe what is asked on the screen and make them think about possible answers.
I could have written the exact same thing three years ago. :D
We called the game, “Help the people” and we still refer to “starites” from time to time. =)
Three years later we’re still playing games together. <3
My daughter always refers to it plainly as “Star”, she wants “to play Star” : Scribblenauts Unlimited is pretty cryptic and unpronounceable for a French kid. :)
Would you have other games suitable for kids to recommend ? I find Steam tight in this category.
Based on what you’ve said so far, I’m guessing your kid(s) are about 3yo? Maybe 2 or 4? At that age, as you can imagine they like colorful, shiny, cartoony, happy little games…you know– like Scribblenauts. =) As they get older, it’s more about what you like to play and want to show them. For me, it was anywhere from puzzle-platformers to action-adventure RPGs to point-and-click games to Hidden Object games– but those are genres I tend to like. I guess my main thing is– don’t play anything with them that you won’t get any enjoyment out of, because they’ll sense that from you and it will turn them off. I never tried “edutainment” games. There’s also a host of games from ForKids, but by the time they came out (on Steam at least) my kids had outgrown them.
So some specifics:
- Games in your library that I’ve played with my kids and they enjoyed (other than Scribblenauts): LEGO games (for me it was Harry Potter and The Hobbit, but Batman and LEGO Worlds is fine too), Ori and the Blind Forest, Tengami (just finished that last week), Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams (still playing this one), Teddy Floppy Ear - Kayaking, STAR WARS Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast, STAR WARS Jedi Knight: Jedi Academy, Costume Quest, Deponia, and Chaos on Deponia. There’s the occasional “bad word” in Deponia, but if you have subtitles on, you can read ahead and click to skip them. ;)
- Other games in your library they might like: Rayman Legends, Sonic Adventure 2, Lumino City
- Games in your library you might try when they get a little older: Trine, Epistory, Unbox, Bastion, Hidden Folks, any decent HOG (such as Nightmares from the Deep, Grim Legends)
- Other games my kids have liked are good for a younger child (3-4yo): Woodle Tree Adventures, Trainz Trouble, Train Town, Lili: Child of Geos, Oceanhorn: Monster of Uncharted Seas, It’s Spring Again, Let There Be Life, Marvin’s Mittens, Snail Bob 2, Sparkle 2 Evo, Disney Princess : My Fairytale Adventure, Castle of Illusion, Sunny Hillride, Teddy Floppy Ear - Mountain Adventure
- Almanac of other games my kids have liked: Driftmoon (their first RPG!), AER Memories of Old, LostWinds 1 and 2, Fire, Captain Morgane and the Golden Turtle, Copoka, Costume Quest 2, Cross of the Dutchman, Detective Grimoire, Duke Grabowski, Mighty Swashbuckler, Disney-Pixar Brave, Faery - Legends of Avalon, Forward to the Sky, Gnomes Garden (and a couple of other time management games), The Happy Hereafter, Heaven’s Hope, Hero of the Kingdom II, Hue, The Little Acre, Moorhuhn - Tiger and Chicken, Papo & Yo (just don’t tell them what it’s really about), The Room, Samorost 3, Save the Furries, Seasons after Fall, Shiny the Firefly, Sneaky Sneaky, Stranded in Time, Tiny Echo, The Uncertain: Episode 1 - The Last Quiet Day, Violett, Witch’s Pranks: Frog’s Fortune Collector’s Edition, Max: The Curse of Brotherhood, The Mysterious Cities of Gold - Secret Paths, Toybox Turbos, World to the West, Cornerstone: The Song Of Tyrim, Scrap Garden, Scrap Garden - The Day Before (free), TY the Tasmanian Tiger, Warden: Melody of the Undergrowth, The Last Tinker: City of Colors, Ember, A Boy and His Blob, TurnOn, Rollers of the Realm, Train Valley, Alchemist, Mystery Maze Of Balthasar Castle (although it’s not a great game).
Special mention to some of my son’s favorite games: Oceanhorn, both aforementioned Star Wars games, Costume Quest 1 & 2 (we played them around Halloween), Max: The Curse of Brotherhood
And my daughter’s favorite games: LEGO Harry Potter (both of them), Snail Bob 2, Disney Princess : My Fairytale Adventure (because she could play it herself).
Anyway, I know that’s way more info than you needed. But I kind of had fun putting it all together and reflecting on some of the great games my kids and I have played together. <3
Good luck!
Jeez, that’s indeed way more info that I can handle but I will certainly pick through this list every now and then. Thank you !
Actually, they are 3 and almost 5. Up till now, I played Lego Batman 2 and Lego Jurassic World “in front of them” and they loved it as much as I did. And of course I played Scribblenauts with them, since they participated much more.
I tried the beginning of Ori & the blind forest with them but found it really sad and the game is quite hard, so I went on by myself.
Awesome that you also play games with your kids. I know when we were growing up the consensus amongst most adults was that video games were bad for kids, but I was lucky that my dad understood technology and I grew up playing games with him. (Albeit probably more mature games than I should have played). So I am happy to do the same with my kids. It’s the evening ritual now for us. My wife gets their bath sorted out and I’ll spend the hour and a half between supper and bath time playing games with them. Lots of mario and lego games, but also plenty of indie games as well. It’s a great bonding experience I think.
And I also loved the lucasarts outlaws game. I was a teenager at the time and it was one my dad and I had played when it came out. So years later I found it again and played it. I never realised at the time that it was sprite based graphics, and it really doesn’t stand up well, but the cutscenes were nice. I agree that call of juarez gunslinger evoked that same feeling when I played it.
My kids are still pretty young, so I remain cautious both on how much they “play” video games and of course what games they “play”. But I’m looking forward to the day they play for real with me, in coop, some Telltale’s Lego or things like that. Although I’m also concerned about how we’ll share the pads without squawking and quarrels, since we’re the three of us. Back to the topic of how much they play, I try to make it exceptional for the moment, like once or twice a week top, usually on Sunday or Saturday, (especially if the weather is bad), so that they don’t get bored too fast. And they have so many other things to do (books, outside games…) that I prefer them fluttering around rather than focusing on video games.
Finally, I would be curious to know some of the games you’ve played in front of them or with them.
Yeah my kids are older so the scope of what we can play is definitely broader. But I have all the humongous entertainment games, which they enjoy. (Putt-putt, fatty bear, pajama sam). They also like the Amanita design games, (Machinarium, botanicula, samarost). There’s the disney games that they like, such as disney infinity, disney universe (this can have up to 4 players), cars etc. We also enjoy some platforming games like tembo the badass elephant and casual games like cat goes fishing or angry birds. They don’t mind taking turns and usually it the game is single played I’ll just watch them and help out if they get stuck, they think I’m some kind of superhero for beating the games so easily. The lego games let you have 2 players, so usually one will be on the controller and me on the keyboard.
For very small kids, the options are limited. There’s “It’s spring again” and “Winnie the pooh” which are basically just interactive stories. The developer “For Kids” also has quite a few casual games that kids may enjoy, albeit you’ll be very bored as an adult. For kids on steam
I just saw you beat Hidden Folks in January. I bought it a few weeks ago. I assume it’s a perfect game to play with kids ?
Well it may be a little frustrating for a younger kid, if they are trying to find the specific things, but my kids enjoyed the animations and sound effects. We’d do one scene together before they got bored usually.
I just tried it today with my elder (almost 5). I saw it can be frustrating (for me too !) and maybe too difficult for a kid, but she proved me she is very observant as she unearthed some things before me.
Thanks for all your advice !
Nice progress, congrats!
I’m curious, did you manage to go into brothers unspoiled about what was gonna happen?
Yes, completely. I think I had read things a long time ago about the story being moving, etc but no spoilers. That being said, the first minutes set the scene in terms of “tearjerking” and you can guess how it’s gonna turn out.
Yes, this. “Predictable,” but still a great story and great game.
Yes totally. It only hit me hard when you feel it through the gameplay tho. Anyway, a great game with good storytelling, even without words.